Domestic Violence
Trafficking in Women
Sexual Harassment
Sexual Assault
Global Violence against Women and Girls
General Information
Best Practices
Law and Policy
Ongoing Developments
Forms of Domestic Violence
Theories of Violence
Prevalence of Domestic Violence
Effects of Domestic Violence
Women's Use of Violence
Dating Violence
Stalking
Animal Abuse and Domestic Violence
LGBTQ Domestic Violence
Evolution of Theories of Violence
Other Causes and Complicating Factors
Myths About Alcohol
Health Effects
Effects on Children
Community Costs of Domestic Violence
HIV/AIDS and Other STIs
Domestic Violence and Housing
Resources for Domestic Violence and Housing Issues
Coordinated Community Response
Victim Protection, Support and Assistance
Law Enforcement, Prosecutions and the Judiciary
Orders for Protection
Child Custody and Family Law Issues
Batterers' Intervention Programs
Lobbying and Community Education
Benefits of Coordination
Adapting the Duluth Model
Goals and Strategies of Intervention
Community Response Participants
Advocacy Guidelines
Advocacy Approaches
Lethal and Extremely Dangerous Behavior
Lethality Assessments
Safety Planning
Shelters and Safehouses
Crisis Centers and Hotlines
Mediation
Role of Health Care Providers
Screening for Domestic Violence
Shuttle or Separate Mediation
Power Balancing
Research and Reports on Mediation
Confidentiality and Support
Screening and Referral
Documentation and Reporting
Creating a Health Care Response
Role of Police
Role of Prosecutors
Forensic Medical Systems
Judiciary
Law Enforcement Reform
Determining the Predominant Aggressor
Officer-Involved Domestic Violence
Prosecutorial Reform
Judicial Responses to Domestic Violence
Specialized Domestic Violence Court Systems
Court Monitoring Programs
Domestic Fatality Review Boards
Child Custody Issues
Divorce
Role of Child Protection Services
Protective Orders and Child Custody
Divorce and Child Custody
Parenting Time and Domestic Violence
Child Protective Services and Domestic Violence
The Hague Convention and Domestic Violence
Resources
Counseling and Treatment
Starting a Batterers' Intervention Program
Influential US Batterers' Intervention Programs
Effectiveness of Batterers' Intervention Programs
History and Theories of Batterers' Intervention Programs in the USA
Batterers' Intervention Programs in CEE/FSU Countries
Best Practices for Batterers' Intervention Programs
United States Standards for Batterers' Intervention Programs
International Domestic Violence Law
Regional Law and Standards
Model Legislation
Sample National Domestic Violence Laws
Protocols and Policies
Methodology for Monitoring the Implementation of Domestic Violence Laws
Drafting Laws on Domestic Violence
UN Treaties on Domestic Violence
UN Resolutions on Domestic Violence
UN Conference Documents on Domestic Violence
Domestic Violence: Special Rapporteur
State Responsibility for Domestic Violence
International Domestic Violence Resources
European Union
Council of Europe - Istanbul Convention
Council of Europe - European Convention on Human Rights
Council of Europe - Resolutions
Organization of American States
Additional Resources
Surveys of National Laws
U.S. Law
Community Policies
Police Protocols
Prosecution Protocols
Health Care Protocols
Batterers' Intervention Programs
Protocols for Victim Support and Assistance
General Information
Training and Advocacy
Law and Policy
Ongoing Developments
Sex Trafficking and Safe Harbor Resource Pack
What Is Trafficking in Women?
Prevalence of Trafficking in Women
Causes and Contributing Factors
Effects and Consequences
Trafficking Routes
Trafficking Violates Women's Human Rights
The Evolution of the Definition of Trafficking
Trafficking and Commercial Sexual Exploitation
Debt Bondage and Trafficking in Women
Distinguishing Trafficking from Migration
Other Forms of Trafficking
Economic Factors
Demand for Women's Sexual Services
The Search for a Better Life and Desire to Travel
Domestic Violence as a Cause of Trafficking in Women
Organized Crime
Conflict Zones and Militarization
Government Policies and Practices
Health Consequences of Trafficking
Legal Consequences of Trafficking
Global Consequences of Trafficking
Trafficking and HIV/AIDS
Protection, Support and Assistance of Victims
Prevention of Trafficking in Women
Return and Reintegration
Common Reactions
Legal Protection
Education and Awareness Raising
Training Programs and Technical Cooperation
Lobbying
International Trafficking Law
Regional Law and Standards
Drafting Laws on Sex Trafficking of Women and Girls
UN Human Trafficking Law
Historical Overview
Trafficking and Women's Human Rights
The Trafficking Protocol and Recent Initiatives
UN Peacekeeping Missions and Trafficking
UN Special Rapporteur on Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children
UN Special Rapporteur on Contemporary Forms of Slavery
Council of Europe
European Union
OSCE
Stability Pact
NATO
General Information
Training and Advocacy
Law and Policy
Ongoing Developments
What is Sexual Harassment in the Workplace?
Theories of Sexual Harassment
Prevalence of Sexual Harassment
Effects of Sexual Harassment
Sexual Harassment Occurs at the Work Site or in a Work Related Environment
Sexual Harassment is Conduct Based on Sex or of a Sexual Nature
Sexual Harassment is Conduct that is Unwelcome or Unwanted
Quid Pro Quo Sexual Harassment
Sexual Harassment that Creates a Hostile Work Environment
Sexual Harassment and the Subordination of Women
Sexual Harassment is an Affront to Dignity
Violence and Power
Perpetuation of Gender Stereotypes
Economic Power Over Women
Prevention Mechanisms, Policies and Strategies
Prevention of Sexual Harassment
Monitoring Workplace Practices and Enforcing Sexual Harassment Law
Employer Responsibilities: Sexual Harassment Policies, Trainings and Complaint Procedures
The Role of Trade Unions and Collective Bargaining
Media and Communication Strategies for Ending Sexual Harassment
Approaches to Gender Equality/ Equal Opportunity Institutions
Allowing NGOs to Bring Litigation on Behalf of Victims
A Statement of Policy
Definition of Harassment and Establishment of a Non-Retaliation Policy
Prevention Procedures/ Training
Designated Complaints Committee or Officer
Informal Complaint or Advice Mechanisms
Complaint Procedures
Investigation Procedures
Disciplinary Procedures
Measures to Correct the Effects of Sexual Harassment
Advocacy Tools for Trade Unions in Combating Sexual Harassment in the Workplace
The Importance of Trade Unions in Combating Sexual Harassment and the Importance of Women in Trade Unions
Role of Trade Unions in Effecting Sexual Harassment Legislation and Regulation Through Political Action and Advocacy
Role of Trade Unions in Effecting Anti-sexual Harassment Policies and Collective Bargaining Agreements in the Workplace
Role of Trade Unions in Educating Workers and Other Community Members on Sexual Harassment and Sexual Assault Issues
Role of Trade Unions in Representing Victims of Sexual Harassment and Penalties for Abusers
The European Union Directive as a Framework for Trade Unions’ Involvement with Sexual Harassment Law and Policy
Opportunities for Collaboration with Other NGOs and Governmental Agencies
Resources on the Issue of Sexual Harassment and Trade Unions
Using the Trade Union
Suggestions for the Trade Union
Resistance from the Trade Union
International Legal Framework
Regional Law and Standards
Domestic Legal Framework
List of Law and Policy Documents
Drafting Laws on Sexual Harassment
UN Conventions
UN Conference Documents
DEVAW
Special Rapporteur
International Labor Organization
Council of Europe
European Union
European Union Treaty Charter Obligations
1976 Equal Treatment Directive and 2002 Sexual Harassment Amendment
Directive on Reversal of the Burden of Proof in Sex Discrimination Cases
EU Council and Parliamentary Resolutions
EU Commission Code of Practice on Measures to Combat Sexual Harassment
Defining Sexual Harassment
Approaches to and Remedies under Sexual Harassment Law
Employer Liability Standards
Barriers to Effective Enforcement of Sexual Harassment Law
Guidelines for Drafting Sexual Harassment Laws
Civil Law
Criminal Law
International Legal Framework
Regional Law and Standards
Domestic Legal Framework Around the World
General Information
Advocacy and Training
Law and Policy
Ongoing Developments
What is Sexual Assault?
Prevalence of Sexual Assault
Forms of Sexual Assault
Consequences of Sexual Assault
Sexual Assault as a Form of Sexual Violence
Consent, Force and Coercion
Types of Sexual Contact
Theories of Sexual Assault
Sexual Assault and Vulnerable Populations
Sexual Assault and Male Dominance
Sexual Assault and Cultural Norms
Sexual Assault and the Media
Biological Theories of Sexual Assault
Marital and Intimate Partner Sexual Assault
Custodial Sexual Assault
Sexual Assault Against Refugees
Sexual Assault During Armed Conflict
Date and Acquaintance Sexual Assault
Street Harassment
Sexual Assault in the Military
Prevalence of Street Harassment and its Consequences
Law and Policy on Street Harassment
International Prevalence of Sexual Assault in the Military
Sexual Assault Within the United States Military
Secondary Victimization
The Military Justice System Response to Sexual Assault
Resources
Health Consequences of Sexual Assault
Victim Reactions to Sexual Assault
Consequences of Sexual Assault on the Community
Sexual Assault, HIV/AIDS and Other STIs
Coordinated Crisis Intervention
Sexual Assault Advocacy Programs
Sexual Assault Nurse Examiners
Sexual Assault Response Teams
Coordinating Councils
Health Care Provider Responses
International Legal Framework
Regional Law and Standards
National Sexual Assault Laws
Drafting Laws on Sexual Assault
Protocols and Policies
Criminal Law and Procedure
Evidentiary Issues and Forensic Medical Institutes
Law Enforcement and Prosecutions
Civil Remedies
Conventions
DEVAW
UN Conference Documents
Ad Hoc International Tribunals
International Criminal Court
UN Special Rapporteurs
Council of Europe
European Union
Laws in the United States
Laws in the CEE/FSU Region
Other Approaches to Sexual Assault Law
Police Protocols
Prosecutor Protocols
Sexual Assault in Higher Education – Laws and Protocols
Defining the Prohibited Contact
Force and Resistance Requirements
Consent and Mens Rea
Procedural Obstacles
Other Law Reform Efforts
Legal Protection and Support for Victims
Crimes Committed in the Name of "Honor"
Dowry-Related Violence
Female Environmental Refugees
Female Genital Mutilation
Femicide
Forced and Child Marriage
Forced/Coerced Sterilization
Gender-Based Asylum
Harmful Practices
Indigenous Women
Maltreatment of Widows
Violence Against LGBT Women
Violence Against the Girl Child
Violence Against Women and HIV/AIDS
Women and Armed Conflict
Women with Disabilities
Prevalence
Consequences
Causes and Risk Factors
Law and Policy
Governmental and Non-Governmental Response
Ongoing Developments
Causes and Risk Factors
Governmental and Nongovernmental Response
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Causes and Risk Factors
Consequences
Law and Policy
Governmental and Non-Governmental Response
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Consequences
Causes and Risk Factors
Law and Policy
Governmental and Non-governmental Response
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Causes and Risk Factors
Law and Policy
Femicide in the CEE/FSU Region
Government Response
NGO Response
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Causes and Risk Factors
Consequences and Effects
Obstetric Fistula
International and Domestic Law and Policy
Forced and Child Marriage Prevention
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Law and Policy
Government and NGO Response
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Causes and Risk Factors
Law and Policy
NGO Response
Ongoing Developments
Canada
European Union
United Kingdom
United States
Acid Attacks & Stove Burning
Breast Ironing
Bride Kidnapping
Forced Pregnancy
Polygamy
Son Preference
Stoning or Flogging of Women
Virginity Tests
Witch Burning & Beheading
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Causes and Risk Factors
Law and Policy
Government and NGO Response
Ongoing Developments
Defining Discrimination against Women and Widows
Prevalence
Causes and Risk Factors
Consequences
Governmental and NGO Response
Law and Policy
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Causes and Risk Factors
Government Response
Law and Policy
NGO Response
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Causes and Risk Factors
Law and Policy
Government and NGO Responses
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Causes and Risk Factors
Consequences
Law and Policy
NGO and Governmental Response
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Consequences and Effects on Women
Causes and Risk Factors
Law and Policy
Government and NGO Response
Ongoing Developments
Prevalence
Causes and Risk Factors
Consequences
Law and Policy
Prevention
Ongoing Developments
Home
Our Work
What's New
Advocacy Tools
International Law
Expert's Corner
Make A Donation
The VAW Monitor
Women's HR Training
Human Rights Reporting
Advocating for New Laws on Violence Against Women and Girls
Women Human Rights Defenders and Safety
United Nations Systems
European System
United Nations Entities
United Nations Documents That Protect Women's Rights
Enforcement Mechanisms In The United Nations
Programs and Funds
Specialized Agencies
Research and Training Institutes
Departments and Offices
Other Entities
UN Treaties on Violence Against Women
UN Resolutions on Violence Against Women
Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action
Basic Human Rights Documents
Complaint Mechanisms
Reporting and Monitoring Mechanisms
Major United Nations Enforcement Bodies
Human Rights Council
UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women
UN Commission on the Status of Women
UN Special Rapporteur on Violence against Women
UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
UN Human Rights Committee
UN Committee on the Rights of the Child
UN Committee Against Torture
UN Committee on Migrant Workers
UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
Complaint Mechanism
Additional Resources
Reporting Mechanism
Complaint Mechanism
Reporting Mechanism
Additional Resources
Complaint Mechanism
Additional Resources
Complaint Mechanism
Additional Resources
Reporting Mechanism
Additional Resources
Complaint Mechanism
Complaint Mechanism
Reporting Mechanism
Additional Resources
Reporting Mechanism
Additional Resources
Complaint Mechanism
Complaint Mechanism
Reporting Mechanism
Additional Resources
Reporting Mechanism
Additional Resources
Reporting Mechanism
Complaint Mechanism
Additional Resources
Institutions and Structure of the European Human Rights System
European Documents That Protect Women's Rights
Enforcement Mechanisms in the European System
Enlargement of the European Union
Council of Europe
European Union
Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe
Regional Cooperation Council
Council of Europe - Istanbul Convention
Council of Europe - European Convention on Human Rights
Council of Europe - European Social Charter
Council of Europe - Resolutions, Reports, Advocacy Campaigns
Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe
European Union
Council of Europe Enforcement Mechanisms
European Union Enforcement Mechanisms
Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe Enforcement Mechanisms
European Court of Human Rights
European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment
European Committee of Social Rights
Court of Justice
Commission
Parliament
EU Accession Process and Women's Rights
NGO Strategies to Impact the EU Accession Process
Home
>
Trafficking in Women
>
Law and Policy
>
International Trafficking Law
>
UN Peacekeeping Missions and Trafficking
UN Peacekeeping Missions and Trafficking in Women
last updated September 1, 2005
As covered in the Explore the Issue section of this website, military and post-combat operations in transitioning states can create ideal environments for trafficking to flourish, a phenomenon which has been documented through reports in numerous countries. In recent years, UN- and
NATO
-led international peacekeeping missions stationed in post-conflict zones have been targeted by the media and human rights watch groups for their failure to adequately confront the issue of trafficking in their assigned countries. The current criticisms leveled at UN peacekeeping operations are twofold. First, in response to evidence that individual peacekeepers have patronized establishments linked to trafficking networks, human rights groups have charged that UN peacekeepers do not face rigorous standards of legal accountability for their actions. Second, rights advocates argue that UN missions have not done enough to actively combat trafficking networks. Below is a summary of current UN standards of accountability and jurisdiction for peacekeeping missions, and accounts of the UN Missions in Bosnia-Herzegovina and Kosovo.
UN Mechanisms Addressing Peacekeeper Accountability
The
Convention on the Privileges and Immunities of the UN
(1946) grants immunity to Representatives of Member States, Officials, and Experts on Missions. Members of the International Police Task Force (some of whom were implicated in trafficking activities in Bosnia-Herzegovina, per below) were accorded status as UN Experts on Missions.
In contrast, UN peacekeepers function under the exclusive criminal jurisdiction of their nation of origin. If the UN Board of Inquiry makes a charge of serious misconduct, the offending peacekeeper is repatriated for prosecution in his home country. In 1993, the UN General Assembly approved a Code of Conduct for all UN peacekeeping missions, which stipulates that peacekeepers “should not indulge in immoral acts of sexual, physical or psychological abuse or exploitation of the local population or United Nations Staff, especially women and children.” However, contests Madeleine Rees, the former top UN human rights official in Bosnia, there is no mechanism to call peacekeepers to account to this code. In an
article
on UN peacekeeper criminal conduct, she is quoted as criticizing that “without an enforceable code of conduct, immunity often means impunity.”
In addition to the
General Assembly’s Code of Conduct
, each UN mission sets specific terms for the conduct, privileges, immunities and jurisdictions of its military and civilian employees. Generally speaking, these terms are often known as Status of Forces Agreements (SOFA). For example, in Kosovo,
UNMIK Regulation 2000/47 on the Status of KFOR and UNMIK Personnel
establishes their immunity from local jurisdiction and the exclusive jurisdiction of their respective nations. In Bosnia, the Annex 1-A and Appendix B of the
Dayton Agreement
establishes the exclusive jurisdiction of peacekeeper’s nation of origin (in other words, only the United States has the right to prosecute members of the U.S. military stationed in Bosnia-Herzegovina).
There has been increasing discussion in the UN Security Council to develop disciplinary procedures for troops and staff workers who violate the Code of Conduct after widely publicized cases of abuse by peacekeepers in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. In June of 2005, the Security Council for the first time held its
5191
st
meeting
to address instances of sexual abuse and exploitation by peacekeepers as they received a
report from the Secretary-General’s Special Adviser on Sexual Exploitation and Abuse
as well as a
report from the Special Committee on Peacekeeping
. While recognizing that the conduct and discipline of troops was primarily the responsibility of troop-contributing countries, the Security Council stressed the shared responsibility of the Secretary-General and all Member States to prevent sexual exploitation and abuse by all categories of peacekeeping personnel and to enforce U.N. standards of conduct in that regard. In her statement, the president of the Security Council, Ellen Margrethe Løj (Denmark) announced that “The Security Council condemns, in the strongest terms, all acts of sexual abuse and exploitation committed by UN peacekeeping personnel.” The two reports submitted contained recommendations that ranged from increasing the role of women in peacekeeping missions to creating uniform standards for all categories of peacekeeping personnel.
Additionally, a
United Nations Department of Peacekeeping Operations (UNDPKO)
policy paper of March 2004 entitled “
Human Trafficking and United Nations Peacekeeping
” established the goal to address human trafficking in relation to UN peacekeeping operations by establishing a system of monitoring and accountability as well as provide support - where mandated - to national anti-trafficking programs and campaigns. Then at the June NATO Summit in Istanbul, NATO Heads of State and the Euro-Atlantic Partnership council endorsed the NATO
Policy on Combating Trafficking in Human Beings
which sets forth a zero-tolerance policy regarding trafficking in human beings by NATO forces and staff and mandates educational and training programs to combat and prevent such activities.
UN Mission in
Bosnia and Herzegovina
The United Nations Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina faced intense media scrutiny in 2000 when an International Police Task Force (IPTF) human rights gender officer reported that IPTF officers and SFOR peacekeepers had patronized nightclubs known to hold trafficked and/or underage women, and in some cases had even purchased women from their traffickers in order to “release” them. An
article
appearing in the Washington Post in December 2001 supported the gender officer’s claims and cited a recent allegation that “some members of the IPTF directly participated in trafficking in women for forced prostitution.” The most serious charge concerned two Romanian policemen who allegedly “recruited Romanian women, purchased false documents for them and then sold the women to Bosnian brothel owners.” While there were some preliminary investigations into the behavior of the officers in question, the UN ultimately decided to take no further action or investigation of the charges.
A 2002 Human Rights Watch reported, entitled
Hopes Betrayed: Trafficking of Women and Girls to Post-Conflict Bosnia and Herzegovina for Forced Prostitution
, addressed the measures taken to punish peacekeeping officers implicated in trafficking activities. The report found that while SFOR and UNMIBH workers could be subject to prosecution by their home countries, they essentially received immunity: “Jurisdictional gaps, lack of political will, and indifference toward the crime of trafficking ensure that the small number of SFOR military contractors and IPTF monitors who participate in trafficking-related offenses do so with nearly complete impunity.” The report argued that “[t]he U.N. has failed to deal in a transparent fashion with allegations of involvement in trafficking-related activities by IPTF monitors and in some cases has failed to investigate those allegations thoroughly.”
In 2001, UNMIBH, with the help of local police, created
STOP
(Special Trafficking Operations Programme) in order to take a more active role in combating trafficking. STOP has coordinated raids and trained/restructured local police forces to better target trafficking rings.
UN Mission in Kosovo
On May 6, 2004, Amnesty International released the results of its research on trafficking in women and girls in Kosovo.
“So does that mean I have rights?” Protecting the Human Rights of Women and Girls Trafficked for Forced Prostitution in Kosovo
details the human rights abuses suffered by victims of trafficking in Kosovo. The report finds that the UN Interim Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK), the NATO-led international military force in Kosovo (KFOR), and the Provisional Institutions of Self-Government in Kosovo (PISG) had not done enough to protect the human rights of women and girls trafficked to, from and within Kosovo. Amnesty International urged these authorities to create measures to halt trafficking operations, to implement adequate protection and reparations to victims, and to ensure that international military and civilian peacekeeping forces suspected of offenses linked to trafficking are brought to justice. Amnesty International estimated that members of the international community comprise 20% of the patronage of trafficked women and girls in Kosovo.
UNMIK quickly denied the allegations of Amnesty International’s report, finding it “highly unbalanced,” according to an
official statement
published May 7, 2004. The statement criticized the “many generalizations” of the AI report, noting that the report did not acknowledge the substantial actions taken by UNMIK and KFOR in the last 2 years, and instead focused heavily on conditions during the “incipient stage” of UNMIK from 1999 to 2001. In addition, it denied substantial misconduct of its peacekeepers, stating that “UNMIK is resolved to ensure that its staff abide by appropriate standards of conduct as outlined in the UN Charter. Disciplinary action against any UNMIK staff found in premises declared ‘off limits’ is strictly enforced irrespective of whether the concerned individual was actually indulging in sexual activities or not. As a result of these measures, during the 2,047 TPIU [Trafficking and Prostitution Investigation Unit] raids and bar checks in 2003, only one international police and 3 international civilian staff were found in ‘off limits’ establishments.”
UNMIK Regulation No. 2000/47 on the Status, Privileges and Immunities of KFOR and UNMIK and Their Personnel in Kosovo (18 August, 2000), which grants peacekeepers stationed in Kosovo immunity from local jurisdiction and exclusive jurisdiction by peacekeepers’ respective nations, has been criticized by the Ombudsperson Institution in Kosovo as being too lax. In the Ombudsperson’s Special Report No. 1, he found that “UNMIK Regulation 2000/47 is incompatible with recognized international standards with respect to the scope of the grant of immunity to KFOR and UNMIK in their institutional capacities. He also found that the Regulation is not 'in accordance with law' in the sense of the European Convention on Human Rights, in part due to its inaccessibility to the public, its unclear provisions and its failure to protect individuals in Kosovo against arbitrary conduct by KFOR or UNMIK or their respective personnel.” The Ombudsman recommended an amendment to limit the immunity of KFOR and UNMIK in their institutional capacity, but to date there has been no amendment issued.
Like UNMIBH, UNMIK has established anti-trafficking measures in recent years. The
Trafficking and Prostitution Investigation Unit
(TPIU) began operations in October 2000, functioning as a special unit of the UN Police Force in Kosovo. TPIU pledged to not treat trafficking victims as suspects, to prosecute perpetrators to the fullest extent of the law, and to arrest and prosecute customers who knowingly use prostitutes who are victims of trafficking.