last updated November 1, 2006
Domestic fatality reviews examine domestic violence related deaths including the events leading up to the death(s) in order to determine what lead to the homicide(s). The goal of the project is to uncover holes or gaps in the various government systems’ responses to domestic violence. The review process is predicated on the knowledge domestic violence is often an escalating crime and that by addressing domestic violence which results in low level injuries we can prevent fatalities. By identifying missed opportunities for intervention and points at which intervention was not effective, the reviews prompt improved identification, intervention and prevention efforts in future cases. The approach of the process is that of working toward system improvement and not placing blame for the death. The review process is a vehicle to identify gaps, barriers and shortcomings in the government response to domestic violence and propose solutions.
The review teams are comprised of representatives from government agencies, including prosecutors, public defenders, judges, police, medical examiners, emergency room doctors, court psychologists, corrections or probation officers, child protection workers, school social workers, etc. The teams also include strong representation from domestic violence advocates and from the community.
Starting a Fatality Review Process
Starting a review process requires a considerable amount of preparation. A team needs to agree on a method of reviewing cases, a shared philosophy about domestic violence, and a membership policy. In order to fully examine the events leading up to a homicide, access to confidential data is important. Fatality Review teams often seek legislative authority to access information protected under data privacy laws. Establishing mechanisms to protect confidentiality in the review process is important. Each team member should be instructed on keeping the case materials and the information discussed in the meetings confidential. The Hennepin County Fatality Review team starts each meeting with its members signing a confidentiality agreement.
Case Review Process
Selecting cases for review is a critical component to the review process. Selection methods vary between groups. The Hennepin County Fatality Review team has elected to not review cases until all direct litigation (i.e. criminal trial, direct appeals) have been completed and or at least a year has passed since the homicide. This waiting period allows for agency representatives to engage in the review process without compromising an ongoing case and with the distance to examine the case, and their agencies role in it, objectively. After a case is selected for review, a staff member identifies records that might be critical to understanding the case. These may include:
Using the records, the staff member compiles a chronology of events leading up to the fatality. The chronologies identify the source of the information. When appropriate, an advocate who worked with the victim may be contacted and through an advocate, the victim’s family. Copies of the chronology are provided to each team member. Additionally team members are selected to have reviewed the original records and to present and/or explain significant information from the files to the group. Using the chronologies and the presentations, the group identifies key case observations and missed opportunities for intervention that may have prevented the homicide and make recommendations based on the issues identified. The team also identifies successful interventions. It also identifies issues that requires further investigation The focus of the process is on the government systems’ response to domestic violence.
Members of the team take the recommendations back to their agencies for implementation. The key case observations, missed opportunities for intervention, and recommendations are also compiled and periodically published. In preparing reports, review teams need to be conscious of protecting the confidentiality of the cases. The reports include public recommendations to government agencies on improving their response to domestic violence, along with the factual basis for that recommendation. An example of a pilot report is available here. The periodic reports, by providing the status of prior recommendations, also allow for holding government agencies accountable for showing improvement. An example of a periodic report, the 2007 Hennepin County Fatality Review Team Report, is available here. Also, the 2008 United Nations expert group report entitled "Good practices in legislation on violence against women" includes information on collecting statistical data of domestic violence cases (Section 3.B). For the Russian version of the recommendations of "Good practices in legislation on violence against women, click here.
For more information on Fatality Review teams:
National Domestic Violence Fatality Review Initiative;
Hennepin County Fatality Review Team;
Washington State Coalition Fatality Review;
New Jersey Domestic Violence Fatality Review;
County of San Diego Health and Human Services Agency Domestic Violence Fatality Review Team.
The Advocates for Human Rights Site Map About the Site
330 Second Avenue South, Suite 800, Minneapolis, MN 55401 USA Phone: (612) 341-3302 Fax: (612) 341-2971 Email: email@example.com
Although Stop Violence Against Women endeavors to provide useful and accurate information, Stop Violence Against Women does not warrant the accuracy of the materials provided. Accordingly, this Web Site and its information are provided "AS IS" without warranty of any kind, express or implied, including but not limited to, the implied warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular use or purpose, or non-infringement. Some jurisdictions do not allow the exclusion of implied warranties, so the above exclusion may not apply to you. We reserve the right to make improvements and/or changes in the format and/or content of the information contained on the Web Site without notice.This information is provided with the understanding that Stop Violence Against Women and its partners are not engaged in rendering legal or other professional services. If legal advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought.
Copyright © 2010 The Advocates for Human Rights. All rights reserved. Permission is granted to use this material for non-commercial purposes with proper attribution to The Advocates for Human Rights.